You've built your email list, crafted compelling subject lines, set up automation sequences, and implemented segmentation strategies. But how do you know if your email marketing efforts are actually working? The answer lies in tracking and analyzing the right metrics. In this article, we'll explore the essential email marketing metrics that every small business should monitor and how to use this data to continuously improve your results.
Why Measuring Email Performance Matters
Tracking the performance of your email campaigns isn't just about collecting numbers—it's about gaining insights that help you:
- Understand what resonates with your audience
- Identify areas for improvement
- Make data-driven decisions
- Justify your marketing investments
- Optimize future campaigns for better results
Without proper measurement, you're essentially sending emails into the void, with no way to know if they're making an impact or how to improve their effectiveness.
Essential Email Marketing Metrics to Track
Let's break down the key metrics into three categories: engagement metrics, conversion metrics, and list health metrics.
Engagement Metrics
Engagement metrics help you understand how recipients interact with your emails.
1. Open Rate
What it is: The percentage of email recipients who opened your email.
How to calculate: (Number of opens ÷ Number of emails delivered) × 100
Why it matters: Open rates indicate the effectiveness of your subject lines and the overall relevance of your emails to your audience.
Industry benchmarks: Average email open rates typically range from 15-25%, varying by industry.
A Note on Apple's Mail Privacy Protection
With Apple's Mail Privacy Protection (MPP) introduced in iOS 15, open rates have become less reliable for users of Apple Mail. MPP pre-loads email content when delivered, which can register as an open regardless of whether the recipient actually opened the email. This means open rates may be artificially inflated, so it's important to consider this when analyzing your data and to place more emphasis on click-through rates and conversions.
2. Click-Through Rate (CTR)
What it is: The percentage of email recipients who clicked on one or more links in your email.
How to calculate: (Number of clicks ÷ Number of emails delivered) × 100
Why it matters: CTR measures how compelling your email content and calls-to-action are. It's a more reliable engagement metric than open rate.
Industry benchmarks: Average CTRs typically range from 2-5%, varying by industry.
3. Click-to-Open Rate (CTOR)
What it is: The percentage of email openers who clicked on a link in your email.
How to calculate: (Number of clicks ÷ Number of opens) × 100
Why it matters: CTOR shows how effective your email content is at driving action once someone has opened your email.
Industry benchmarks: Average CTORs typically range from 10-20%, varying by industry.
Average engagement metrics by industry (source: Email Benchmark Study 2023)
Conversion Metrics
Conversion metrics help you understand the business impact of your email marketing.
4. Conversion Rate
What it is: The percentage of email recipients who completed a desired action (making a purchase, filling out a form, etc.) after clicking through from your email.
How to calculate: (Number of conversions ÷ Number of emails delivered) × 100
Why it matters: Conversion rate measures how effectively your emails drive business results.
Industry benchmarks: Average conversion rates typically range from 1-5%, varying significantly by industry and conversion type.
5. Revenue Per Email (RPE)
What it is: The average revenue generated by each email sent.
How to calculate: Total revenue generated ÷ Number of emails delivered
Why it matters: RPE directly ties your email marketing to revenue, helping you understand the financial impact of your campaigns.
6. Return on Investment (ROI)
What it is: The overall return on your email marketing investment.
How to calculate: [(Revenue generated - Cost of email marketing) ÷ Cost of email marketing] × 100
Why it matters: ROI helps you determine if your email marketing efforts are profitable and how they compare to other marketing channels.
Industry insights: Email marketing typically delivers an average ROI of $36-$42 for every $1 spent, making it one of the highest-ROI marketing channels available.
List Health Metrics
List health metrics help you understand the quality and growth of your email list.
7. List Growth Rate
What it is: The rate at which your email list is growing.
How to calculate: [(New subscribers - Unsubscribes) ÷ Total subscribers at beginning of period] × 100
Why it matters: List growth rate indicates the health and sustainability of your email marketing program.
8. Unsubscribe Rate
What it is: The percentage of recipients who unsubscribe after receiving an email.
How to calculate: (Number of unsubscribes ÷ Number of emails delivered) × 100
Why it matters: A high unsubscribe rate may indicate that your content isn't relevant to your audience or that you're emailing too frequently.
Industry benchmarks: Average unsubscribe rates are typically below 0.5%.
9. Bounce Rate
What it is: The percentage of emails that couldn't be delivered.
How to calculate: (Number of bounced emails ÷ Number of emails sent) × 100
Types of bounces:
- Soft bounces: Temporary delivery issues (full inbox, server down)
- Hard bounces: Permanent delivery issues (invalid email address)
Why it matters: High bounce rates can harm your sender reputation and reduce deliverability.
Industry benchmarks: Aim for bounce rates below 2%.
10. Spam Complaint Rate
What it is: The percentage of recipients who mark your email as spam.
How to calculate: (Number of spam complaints ÷ Number of emails delivered) × 100
Why it matters: Spam complaints significantly damage your sender reputation and can get you blacklisted by email service providers.
Industry benchmarks: Keep spam complaint rates below 0.1%.
Setting Up Effective Measurement Systems
Tools for Tracking Email Metrics
Most email service providers (ESPs) offer built-in analytics that track basic metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and unsubscribes. For more advanced tracking, consider:
- Google Analytics: Track website behavior after email clicks
- UTM parameters: Add to your email links to track campaign performance in analytics tools
- CRM integration: Connect your email platform with your CRM to track the full customer journey
- Dedicated email analytics tools: Litmus, Email on Acid, or other specialized tools for deeper insights
Creating a Measurement Framework
Follow these steps to establish an effective measurement system:
- Define your goals: Determine what you want to achieve with your email marketing (sales, leads, engagement, etc.)
- Select relevant metrics: Choose metrics that align with your goals
- Set up tracking: Configure your ESP and other tools to track your selected metrics
- Establish benchmarks: Research industry standards and establish your own baseline metrics
- Create a reporting schedule: Determine how often you'll review and analyze your metrics
Example of an email marketing analytics dashboard
Using Metrics to Improve Your Email Marketing
Identifying Areas for Improvement
Different metrics point to different areas for improvement:
- Low open rates: Focus on improving subject lines, sender name, or send times
- Good open rates but low click-through rates: Improve email content, offers, or calls-to-action
- Good click-through rates but low conversions: Optimize landing pages or the post-click experience
- High unsubscribe rates: Reconsider email frequency, content relevance, or segmentation
A/B Testing for Continuous Improvement
Use A/B testing to systematically improve your email performance:
- Identify what to test: Subject lines, content, CTAs, send times, etc.
- Create two versions: Vary only one element between versions
- Split your audience: Send each version to a comparable segment of your list
- Analyze results: Determine which version performed better
- Implement findings: Apply what you learned to future campaigns
A/B Testing Example
A small e-commerce business tested two different subject lines for their monthly sale announcement:
- Version A: "Our Monthly Sale is Here!" (18% open rate, 2.1% CTR)
- Version B: "Save 25% on Your Favorites Today Only" (27% open rate, 3.5% CTR)
Version B performed significantly better, demonstrating that specific, value-focused subject lines with urgency outperformed general announcements. The business implemented this finding in future campaigns, resulting in a 32% overall increase in email revenue.
Benchmarking Against Industry Standards
While your own historical data is the most relevant benchmark, industry standards can provide context for your performance. Consider:
- How your metrics compare to industry averages
- Whether underperforming metrics indicate opportunities for improvement
- Whether overperforming metrics reveal competitive advantages you should leverage
Advanced Measurement Strategies
Customer Lifetime Value (CLV) from Email
Measure the long-term value of subscribers, not just immediate conversions:
- Track purchases over time from email subscribers
- Compare CLV of email subscribers vs. non-subscribers
- Analyze how different email acquisition sources affect CLV
Attribution Modeling
Understand email's role in the broader customer journey:
- First-touch attribution: Credits email if it was the first touchpoint
- Last-touch attribution: Credits email if it was the last touchpoint before conversion
- Multi-touch attribution: Distributes credit across all touchpoints in the customer journey
Cohort Analysis
Track how different groups of subscribers perform over time:
- Compare engagement of subscribers acquired from different sources
- Analyze how subscriber behavior changes over their lifecycle
- Identify patterns in when and why subscribers become inactive
Common Measurement Pitfalls to Avoid
Focusing on Vanity Metrics
Don't get distracted by metrics that look good but don't translate to business results. For example, a large list size means little if engagement is low.
Ignoring Context
Remember that metrics need context to be meaningful:
- A 15% open rate might be poor for a welcome email but good for a re-engagement campaign
- Different industries have different benchmark standards
- Seasonal factors can significantly impact metrics
Not Segmenting Your Analysis
Overall metrics can mask important insights. Break down your analysis by:
- Subscriber segments
- Campaign types
- Device and email client
- Time of day or day of week
Overlooking Long-Term Trends
While individual campaign metrics are important, also track how your email performance evolves over time. Look for:
- Gradual increases or decreases in key metrics
- Seasonal patterns
- The impact of strategy changes over multiple campaigns
Final Thoughts
Effective measurement is what transforms email marketing from an art to a science. By tracking the right metrics, analyzing the data, and applying the insights, you can continuously improve your email marketing performance and drive better results for your small business.
Remember that the goal isn't perfect metrics—it's progress. Focus on gradual improvement over time, testing new approaches, and learning from both successes and failures. Even small improvements in key metrics can translate to significant business impact when compounded across your entire email program.
Most importantly, don't let measurement become overwhelming. Start with the metrics most relevant to your business goals, establish a regular rhythm of analysis, and use what you learn to make data-driven decisions that move your email marketing forward.
Comments (1)
This breakdown of metrics is so helpful! I've been focusing almost exclusively on open rates until now, but I can see that I need to pay more attention to click-through and conversion rates to really understand how my emails are performing. The A/B testing framework will be really useful for improving my campaigns.
Leave a Comment